On this page you will read detailed information about Court Fees Act 1870.
As a legal professional, you have likely encountered the Court Fees Act of 1870 in your work. This 150-year-old legislation continues to have profound implications for the Indian judicial system. With this act, the British colonial rulers sought to codify and standardize court fees and stamp duties across British India. Understanding the origins and key provisions of the Court Fees Act provides essential context for the development of India’s modern court system. In this article, we will explore the background that led to the act, its main objectives and effects, and how it has shaped court fees and access to justice over the past century and a half. Tracing the evolution of this foundational legislation grants insight into both colonial rule and India’s post-independence legal framework.
Overview of the Court Fees Act 1870
Enacted by British India, the Court Fees Act, 1870 consolidated and amended the law relating to court-fees. The main objectives of the Act were to revise court fees for legal proceedings in courts and to ensure uniformity in the levy of fees in all courts across British India.
Court Fees Defined
Court fees refer to the charges levied upon litigants for instituting or contesting legal proceedings in courts. The Act codified and simplified the rules for the levy of court fees in different types of civil and criminal proceedings.
Types of Fees
The Act classified court fees into six categories: ad valorem fees on the value of the subject matter, fixed fees, fees on petitions, memorandum of appeal and applications, process fees, copying fees and search fees. Ad valorem fees were charged at a percentage of the value involved in the suit and were the principal source of court fee revenue.
Exemptions and Rebates
To provide access to justice for all, the Act exempted certain individuals and institutions from paying court fees. Indigent people, government institutions and certain religious or charitable bodies were exempted wholly or partially from paying fees. The courts were also given discretion to grant rebates on the fees in some circumstances.
Stamps in Lieu of Cash
The Act introduced the use of court fee stamps in place of cash for the payment of fees. Litigants were required to affix stamps of requisite amount to their petitions, plaints or other documents in order to institute or contest proceedings in courts. The stamps could be purchased and affixed or impressed upon the documents.
The Court Fees Act, 1870 continues to govern the levy of court fees for civil and criminal proceedings in district courts in India. Several amendments have been made to the Act over the years to revise the fee rates and categories. The Act provides an important source of revenue for the government and regulates access to the legal system.
In the previous post, we had shared information about Anti Superstition Laws in India: An Overview, so read that post also.
What Are Court Fees Under the Act?
Court fees refer to the charges levied on legal proceedings and documents in courts of law. The Court Fees Act of 1870 standardized and streamlined the system of levying fees in courts across British India. Under the Act, fees are charged on the basis of the value of the suit or case, the amount or value of the subject matter in dispute, or a fixed sum – depending on the nature of the suit or document.
Fees Based on Value of Suit
For most civil suits, ad valorem fees are charged depending on the value of the relief claimed in the plaint. The fee increases progressively with the pecuniary value of the suit. For example, the fee for a suit valued at Rs. 1,000 would be Rs. 10, while it would be Rs. 200 for a suit valued at Rs. 10,000. This ensures that the wealthier litigants who dispute higher stakes pay higher fees.
Fees for Probate and Administration
For probate of wills and letters of administration, fees are charged on the basis of the value of the estate. For example, if the value of the estate is Rs. 50,000, the fee would be Rs. 200. For estates exceeding Rs. 50 lakhs in value, the maximum fee is capped at Rs. 15,000.
Fixed Fees
Fixed fees are charged for certain categories of documents like copies, summonses and petitions. For example, the fee for filing a written statement or affidavit in a civil suit is fixed at Rs. 5. The fee for a copy or translation of a judgment is Rs. 5 per page. Fixed fees provide certainty and prevent excessively high charges for routine legal processes.
The Court Fees Act aims to charge litigants and petitioners in a fair and equitable manner while generating revenue for the government. The rules for calculation of fees are clearly laid out to prevent arbitrariness. At the same time, the fees are not so high as to deny access to justice for the poor. By rationalizing and standardizing court fees across British India, the Act made the legal system more transparent, accessible and affordable for the common people.
Calculation of Ad Valorem Court Fees
Ad valorem court fees refers to the fees charged as a percentage of the value of the subject matter of the suit. It is calculated based on the value of the property or the amount claimed in the plaint. The Court Fees Act 1870 specifies the ad valorem fees levied on different types of suits.
Suits Relating to Property
For suits relating to property such as declarations of title or right, possession or partition, the ad valorem fees is calculated based on the value of the property. The plaintiff has to file an affidavit stating the value of the property and the court fees is charged at a prescribed percentage of such value. For example, in a suit for possession of immovable property, the court fees would be 1% of the value of the property or Rs. 200, whichever is higher.
Suits Relating to Money
In suits relating to money such as those for the recovery of money due on a mortgage, bond or other contract, the court fees is a percentage of the amount claimed. For instance, in a suit to recover money due on a promissory note, the fees would be 2% of the amount claimed subject to a maximum of Rs. 200. If the amount claimed exceeds Rs. 1 lakh, additional fees are charged for every Rs. 10,000 claimed.
Other Suits
For other suits not specifically provided for, such as suits relating to accounts or partnership, ad valorem fees are calculated based on the amount at which the relief sought is valued in the plaint or memorandum of appeal. If no such amount is specified, the court has the discretion to determine the amount based on the subject matter of the suit.
The ad valorem fees aim to charge higher fees for more valuable suits and claims. However, the Court has the power to scrutinize the valuation given in the plaint and can order re-valuation if it finds the valuation given is insufficient. The plaintiff will have to pay the deficient court fees, if any, before the suit can proceed.
Court Fee Stamps Under the Act
The Court Fees Act of 1870 mandated the use of court fee stamps for legal documents filed in courts across British India. These stamps were essentially a form of taxation implemented on judicial processes. The value of the stamps varied based on the nature of the documents and the court in which they were filed.
Stamp Values
The values of the court fee stamps were fixed for each class of document in each court. For example, in the High Courts, a copy of a decree or order cost one rupee, a memorandum of appeal cost five rupees, and a suit valuation cost ad valorem fee. In the District Courts, a summary suit cost two rupees, a suit for money or goods cost two percent of the value, and a suit for declaration of title cost five rupees. The values were carefully indexed based on the nature of the judicial process.
Payment Methods
The court fee stamps could be purchased at government treasuries and sub-treasuries in the required values and affixed to the documents before filing. As an alternative, the fees could be paid in cash at the time of filing, in which case the amount was endorsed as a receipt on the document. The option to pay in cash provided convenience, although there was a risk of the receipt becoming detached from the document.
Exemptions
The Act provided exemptions from the payment of court fees for certain classes of individuals and documents. Notable exemptions included petitions by paupers, applications by public officers in their official capacity, and documents filed by the Government. These exemptions ensured that the fee requirement did not become an impediment for the less privileged to access justice.
In summary, the Court Fees Act of 1870 introduced a structured fee schedule for accessing the courts of law in British India. The fees generated revenue for the Government but also risked becoming an obstacle for some. The exemptions and option to pay in cash provided a balance, upholding the principles of justice and equity.
Exemptions From Payment of Court Fees
As per the Court Fees Act of 1870, certain individuals and organizations are exempted from paying court fees.
Government Litigation
The Central Government and State Governments are exempted from paying any court fees in respect of any suit, appeal or other proceedings. Local authorities, public officers acting in their official capacity and any person suing or being sued on behalf of the Government are also exempt.
Paupers
Any person who is unable to pay the prescribed court fees due to poverty or indigence can file a petition requesting exemption. The court has the discretion to either fully or partially exempt the individual from paying the fees after conducting an inquiry into the person’s financial status.
Charitable Institutions
Recognized charitable institutions are exempt from paying court fees in respect of any suit or proceedings instituted or defended by them. To claim this exemption, the institution must provide a certificate from the relevant authority recognizing it as a charitable organization.
Members of Armed Forces
Members of naval, military and air forces of India are exempt from paying court fees in respect of any proceeding to which they are a party in their official capacity. This covers suits and appeals filed during active service and for two years after retirement. The court has discretion to extend this period in exceptional circumstances.
To conclude, the Court Fees Act aims to ensure that access to justice is available for all citizens regardless of their financial means. The exemptions provided prevent vulnerable groups from being barred due to inability to pay the prescribed court fees. At the same time, they do not overly burden the judiciary and government with loss of revenue. The exemptions strike a balance between the interests of citizens seeking justice and the practical needs of maintaining a functioning judicial system.
Consequences of Non-Payment of Court Fees
Failure to pay the required court fees as per the Court Fees Act of 1870 can have significant consequences. If the prescribed court fees are not paid, the plaint, petition or memorandum of appeal shall be rejected under the Act.
The plaint, petition or memorandum of appeal is the document filed to institute a suit or proceeding in a court of law. If the necessary court fees are not paid on such a document, the court will not take cognizance of the matter and dismiss the case.
No refund of court fees
The court fees paid in pursuance of the Act shall not be refunded under any circumstances. The fees are collected to meet the expenses of the courts and government machinery. Once paid, the fees will not be refunded even if the plaint or petition is rejected or the suit or proceeding is dismissed for any reason.
Penalty for false statements
If a plaintiff or petitioner makes a false statement in the plaint or petition regarding the value of the subject matter of the suit or proceeding, in order to avoid payment of proper court fees, they shall be liable to pay penalty up to ten times the deficient amount of court fees. The plaintiff or petitioner may also face civil or criminal prosecution for providing false information to the court.
To conclude, non-payment or evasion of court fees can prove very costly to the litigants. It is always advisable to pay the accurate court fees on time as per the provision of the Court Fees Act to avoid legal complications and penalties. The consequences of non-compliance with the Act should not be taken lightly.
Amendments Made to the Court Fees Act
The Court Fees Act of 1870 has undergone several amendments since its enactment to expand its scope and applicability. In 1877, the Act was first amended to consolidate the law relating to fees taken in courts and public offices in British India. This amendment empowered the state governments to make rules for fees in courts subordinate to the High Courts.
In 1879, the Act was amended again to exempt petitioners from court fees in certain cases, including insolvency petitions by debtors. The amendment also gave state governments the authority to grant exemptions from payment of court fees for certain categories of legal proceedings.
A major amendment was made in 1922 to align the fee rates with the increasing costs of litigation. The amendment introduced ad valorem fees based on the value of the suits and appeals. It also increased the fees for probate and administration cases. Furthermore, the state governments were authorized to exempt any class of persons from payment of court fees.
Subsequent amendments in 1926, 1937, 1940, 1942 and 1946 further increased the court fees to account for rising costs and also introduced fee exemptions for certain categories of litigants, such as members of the armed forces. In 1959, another amendment empowered the state governments to make rules for refund or remission of court fees in certain circumstances.
The most recent amendments made in 1993 and 2002 streamlined and simplified the calculation of ad valorem fees based on the value of suits. They also enhanced the fee rates substantially due to rising litigation costs. However, exemptions and remissions provided under previous amendments have been retained under the current Act.
In summary, the Court Fees Act of 1870 has evolved over time through various amendments to align fee rates with increasing judicial expenditure, expand its scope and applicability, and provide relief to certain categories of litigants. The Act continues to govern the levy of court fees for all suits, appeals and other proceedings in civil and criminal courts in India.
Criticisms and Recommendations for Reform
The Court Fees Act of 1870 has received criticism over the years and there have been calls for reform. One of the primary criticisms is that the fees are too high, especially for poor and marginalized groups, making the legal system inaccessible. The fees were set over a century ago and have not been revised since, despite inflation and increased costs of living.
To address this, reformers recommend indexing fees to account for inflation and increasing costs. Fees should be re-evaluated periodically based on current economic factors to ensure they remain reasonable and fair. Lowering select fees, especially for indigent individuals, could also improve access to justice.
Another criticism is the lack of uniformity in how fees are levied across courts. Fees for the same types of cases and procedures can vary between district courts, causing confusion and inequality. Reformers suggest standardizing court fees across the country based on the nature of the case and services provided. Uniformity and predictability in the fee schedule would benefit both the courts and those accessing the legal system.
The system of fee collection and management has also received criticism for being inefficient, time-consuming, and error-prone. Most fees are paid manually at court counters in cash, requiring extensive time, resources and paperwork to collect, deposit, account for, and audit fees.
Modernizing the fee payment system by accepting digital payments and automating parts of the accounting and auditing process could address these inefficiencies, reduce costs, and minimize errors.
While the Court Fees Act of 1870 aimed to make the courts self-sufficient, critics argue it has ultimately made justice inaccessible for many. Reforms to make fees more affordable, standardize and streamline the fee structure, and modernize the payment system are necessary to uphold the principles of equality and justice for all. Overall, most agree that reasonable access to the legal system should not be barred by one’s ability to pay.
FAQs on Court Fees Act 1870
The Court Fees Act of 1870 established a uniform system of court fees in British India. If you have questions about this Act, here are some common FAQs:
The Act regulated the fees payable in civil courts for different types of processes like filing suits, appeals, applications and petitions. It also regulated the mode of payment of the fees.
The main objectives of the Court Fees Act were:
I) To make the judicial system more accessible to people from all economic backgrounds.
II) To make the system of court fees uniform throughout British India.
III) To provide the government revenue from the court fees.
The Act classified suits into different categories based on the value of the subject matter of the suit. The court fees were charged ad valorem, which means in proportion to the value. Suits of higher value attracted higher fees.
The Act allowed courts to exempt indigent persons from paying the prescribed court fees or allow them to pay smaller fees. The courts could also postpone or remit the fees of indigent persons.
Yes, the Act prescribed maximum fees for certain types of suits and processes to avoid fees that were disproportionate to the subject matter. For example, the maximum fee for a suit for possession of immovable property was Rs 1,000.
The Court Fees Act of 1870 brought uniformity and affordability to the system of judicial fees in British India. By answering common questions about its provisions and objectives, one can gain a good understanding of this important legislation.
Conclusion
As we have seen, the Court Fees Act of 1870 has had a profound influence on India’s legal system. By regulating court fees and establishing a uniform structure, it enabled greater access to the courts for people of all backgrounds. While amendments have been made over the years, the core principles remain relevant today. Looking to the future, the Act will likely continue shaping how justice is administered. We must strive to uphold its founding vision of an open and impartial judicial system. Through thoughtful stewardship of this important legislation, India can build on the progress made and ensure equal rights for all under the law.
Disclaimer
The information and services on this website are not intended to and shall not be used as legal advice. You should consult a Legal Professional for any legal or solicited advice. While we have good faith and our own independent research to every information listed on the website and do our best to ensure that the data provided is accurate. However, we do not guarantee the information provided is accurate and make no representation or warranty of any kind, express or implied, regarding the accuracy, adequacy, validity, reliability, availability, or completeness of any information on the Site. UNDER NO CIRCUMSTANCES SHALL WE HAVE ANY LIABILITY TO YOU FOR ANY LOSS OR DAMAGE OF ANY KIND INCURRED AS A RESULT OR RELIANCE ON ANY INFORMATION PROVIDED ON THE SITE. YOUR USE OF THE SITE AND YOUR RELIANCE ON ANY INFORMATION ON THE SITE IS SOLELY AT YOUR OWN RISK. Comments on this website are the sole responsibility of their writers so the accuracy, completeness, veracity, honesty, factuality and politeness of comments are not guaranteed.
So friends, today we talked about Court Fees Act 1870, hope you liked our post.
If you liked the information about Court Fees Act 1870, then definitely share this article with your friends.
Knowing about laws can make you feel super smart ! If you find value in the content you may consider joining our not for profit Legal Community ! You can ask unlimited questions on WhatsApp and get answers. You can DM or send your name & number to 8208309918 on WhatsApp
