On this page you will read detailed information about Role of the Law Commission of India.
As an attorney or legal scholar in India, you likely follow the work of the Law Commission closely. Established in 1955 to review and recommend reform of laws in India, the Law Commission plays an integral role in shaping the development of law and policy. However, in recent years some critics have questioned whether the Commission remains as relevant or impactful as in decades past. Before determining how the Commission could improve or whether it requires reform, it is important to first evaluate its role and purpose in India’s legal system. This article examines the key responsibilities and recent work of the Law Commission to assess its current effectiveness and value. With a deeper understanding of how the Commission operates and influences law reform, you will be better equipped to judge if and how it needs to adapt to best serve the future of India’s legal framework.
What Is the Law Commission of India?
The Law Commission of India acts as an advisory body to the Government of India on legal reforms. Established in 1955, the Commission aims to keep Indian laws up-to-date with the changing social and economic conditions of the country.
The Commission, headed by a full-time Chairperson, consists of two part-time Members – one being an eminent jurist and the other being an expert in the particular field of law under review. The Commission is serviced by a small Secretariat. The Chairperson and Members are appointed by the Central Government.
The Law Commission has so far submitted 277 comprehensive reports on various subjects. Some of the important reports include those on Hindu law reform, amendment of the Indian Evidence Act and the Indian Penal Code, etc. Many of the recommendations of the Commission have been incorporated into legislation. The Commission, from time to time, also undertakes studies and research in law and review of existing laws in India on its own initiative. It also examines the laws on a reference made to it by the Central Government through the Ministry of Law and Justice.
The pivotal roles and responsibilities of the Law Commission include:
- Review and reform of existing statutes, acts and regulations
- Examination of court decisions for making recommendations to bring about uniformity
- Consideration of earlier law commission reports
- Undertaking research in jurisprudence and comparative studies of legal systems of other countries
- Advising Central Government on any legal matter referred to it.
In summary, the Law Commission of India aims to facilitate legal reform to meet the changing needs of Indian society. It has been instrumental in shaping many laws and policies in India through continuous review and recommendations to the Government. The Commission plays a vital role in the development and updating of the Indian legal system to ensure it remains fair, unbiased, accessible, and transparent.
Major Recommendations of the Law Commission
The Law Commission of India has published over 250 reports recommending various legal reforms since its inception. Some of the major recommendations by the Commission include:
Uniform Civil Code
The Commission has recommended enacting a uniform civil code to replace the personal laws based on scriptures and customs of various religious communities in India. A uniform civil code will help in achieving the goal of unity and integrity of the nation. It aims to protect the rights of vulnerable groups and promote national integration.
Decriminalization of Suicide
The Commission recommended decriminalizing suicide and attempted suicide under Section 309 of the Indian Penal Code. It argued that suicidal behavior requires medical and psychiatric care instead of legal punishment. Decriminalization will reduce the stigma around mental health issues and encourage people to seek help.
Banning Triple Talaq
The Commission has repeatedly recommended banning the practice of triple talaq (instant divorce) among Muslims. It contended that triple talaq is unconstitutional, arbitrary and violates the right to equality. Banning triple talaq will grant Muslim women the right to divorce through a judicial process available to women from other religious communities.
In the previous post, we had shared information about Chargesheet : Everything You Need to Know, so read that post also.
Reform of Rape Laws
The Commission recommended significant reforms in rape laws to make them more progressive and gender-neutral. This includes making marital rape an offense, removing the requirement of corroboration of a rape victim’s testimony, and making rape laws gender-neutral by including male victims. These reforms will make the legal system more sensitive towards victims of sexual violence.
Decriminalization of Gambling
The Commission recommended decriminalizing gambling to curb illegal gambling activities. It argued that regulated gambling can become a source of revenue for the government. However, there is a need to put in place strong regulations to prevent addiction and protect vulnerable groups. Decriminalization may boost tourism and employment in some sectors.
The recommendations of the Law Commission have played an important role in initiating legal reforms in India, though not all recommendations have translated into legislations. The Commission continues to examine various legal issues to suggest reforms to realize the constitutional vision of justice, equality and dignity of all citizens.
Criticisms and Shortcomings of the Commission
The Law Commission of India has received criticism on several fronts. Some argue that the Commission lacks true independence and authority. As an executive body, its members and chairperson are appointed by the central government. Critics claim this structure prevents the Commission from being fully independent and unbiased in its reviews and recommendations.
Additionally, the Commission’s reports and suggestions are not binding. Parliament and state legislatures are under no obligation to adopt or even consider the Commission’s proposals. While the Commission aims to review and reform archaic laws, there is no mechanism to ensure these reforms come to fruition. The Commission is limited to making recommendations, with no way to enforce changes or updates to statutory laws.
The Commission has also been criticized for delays and inefficiencies in its work. There are often long periods between reports and reviews on key issues. The Commission struggles with a large backlog of laws requiring review, as well as difficulties in obtaining data and input from various stakeholders. These inefficiencies, combined with a lack of obligation for legislatures to act, mean many of the Commission’s recommendations may go unaddressed for years.
Further, the Commission’s narrow scope and limited resources prevent it from addressing many significant issues. It focuses primarily on reviewing and reforming existing laws, rather than evaluating the overall coherence and consistency of the legal system. The Commission also lacks subject-area experts, relying instead on part-time members. This structure limits its ability to conduct in-depth reviews on complex, specialized areas of law.
While the Law Commission of India aims to bring legal reform and harmonization, its efforts are constrained by a lack of independence, limited authority, operational inefficiencies, and narrow scope. Reforms to address these key criticisms and shortcomings could strengthen the Commission’s role in updating India’s legal framework to meet the needs of the 21st century. Overall, the Commission remains an advisory body, lacking the full mandate and means to drive legal transformation on its own.
Evaluating the Implementation of Recommendations
The Law Commission of India was established in 1955 to review existing laws and recommend reforms. However, many of the Law Commission’s recommendations have not been implemented for various reasons. Evaluating the success of implemented reforms and barriers preventing further action is key to improving the law reform process in India.
Implementation Rate
- According to various analyses, only about 25-30% of the Law Commission’s recommendations have actually been implemented through legislation. This implementation rate is quite low, especially considering the Commission has submitted over 250 reports proposing various legal reforms.
- Reasons cited for the low implementation rate include lack of political will, conflicts with existing laws, and resource constraints in drafting and passing new legislation. Improving the implementation rate will require addressing these underlying issues.
Evaluating Implemented Reforms
- Reforms that have been implemented, such as amendments to the Code of Criminal Procedure and the Indian Penal Code, should be evaluated to determine their effectiveness and identify any need for further changes. Evaluations could analyze factors like the reform’s impact on legal proceedings, access to justice, and law enforcement.
- Undertaking comprehensive evaluations of major reforms would provide valuable feedback to improve future recommendations and build support for additional changes. Evaluations should aim to be independent, data-driven, and make constructive suggestions for optimizing implemented legal reforms.
Overcoming Barriers
- To overcome barriers like lack of political will or resource constraints, the Law Commission and other stakeholders must build widespread consensus around the need for and benefits of proposed reforms. Demonstrating how recommendations align with principles of justice, equality and good governance can help generate support.
- The Commission should also focus recommendations on high-priority areas and feasible changes that can be implemented efficiently without major resource investments. Starting with smaller reforms may make the overall law reform process more achievable and effective.
In summary, evaluating implemented legal reforms and developing strategies to increase the acceptance and adoption of recommendations is critical to optimizing the Law Commission of India’s role in law reform. With some adjustments, the Commission can become an even more influential and impactful advocate for positive change within India’s legal system.
The Future and Continuing Relevance of the Law Commission
The Law Commission of India has played an integral role in legal reform and updating statutes to align with the changing society since its establishment in 1955. However, some argue its relevance may be diminishing. This section evaluates the future role and importance of the Law Commission.
The Law Commission’s raison d’être is reviewing and updating obsolete and outdated laws and recommending legislative reform. It studies various aspects of law and submits reports to the Government. Over 270 reports submitted to date have formed the basis of many legislative enactments and judicial pronouncements. The Commission has reviewed crucial laws related to women and children, environmental protection, arbitration, among others.
However, in recent years, the Commission has received criticism due to delays in report submission and recommendations not being implemented. Some see the Commission as lacking teeth without a mandate to draft bills. Others argue law reform can be achieved through other bodies like expert committees.
Despite these concerns, the Law Commission remains uniquely positioned to recommend forward-looking, comprehensive legal reform. It has the expertise and experience to conduct in-depth studies on complex issues. The Commission should focus on key areas like uniform civil code, data protection and privacy laws which require extensive research and consultation. It must submit reports in a timelier manner and follow up to ensure recommendations translate to legislation.
The Law Commission is an institution that should be strengthened rather than diminished. With more autonomy, focus and pro-activeness, it can continue to facilitate progressive law reform suited to India’s aspirations as a global leader. The need for an independent body to review laws and recommend changes does not disappear with time. The Law Commission’s role in shaping laws for the future remains as crucial as ever. Overall, the Commission’s importance lies not in the number of reports submitted but in their quality and impact. Its relevance will continue as long as its recommendations are bold, visionary and attuned to India’s complex realities.
Conclusion
As you have seen, the Law Commission of India plays an integral role in the evolution and development of the Indian legal system. For over 60 years, it has shaped laws to align with the changing needs and values of Indian society. While its recommendations are non-binding, many have been adopted and implemented as Acts of Parliament, demonstrating its significant influence. Going forward, the Commission will likely continue to push for progressive legal reform in India on important issues like uniform civil code, bail reforms, and privacy laws. Overall, the Law Commission of India deserves recognition and support for its meaningful work in helping India’s laws and legal system better serve the needs of all citizens. Though not without its critics and controversies, the Commission’s role in India’s democracy remains essential.
Disclaimer
The information and services on this website are not intended to and shall not be used as legal advice. You should consult a Legal Professional for any legal or solicited advice. While we have good faith and our own independent research to every information listed on the website and do our best to ensure that the data provided is accurate. However, we do not guarantee the information provided is accurate and make no representation or warranty of any kind, express or implied, regarding the accuracy, adequacy, validity, reliability, availability, or completeness of any information on the Site. UNDER NO CIRCUMSTANCES SHALL WE HAVE ANY LIABILITY TO YOU FOR ANY LOSS OR DAMAGE OF ANY KIND INCURRED AS A RESULT OR RELIANCE ON ANY INFORMATION PROVIDED ON THE SITE. YOUR USE OF THE SITE AND YOUR RELIANCE ON ANY INFORMATION ON THE SITE IS SOLELY AT YOUR OWN RISK. Comments on this website are the sole responsibility of their writers so the accuracy, completeness, veracity, honesty, factuality and politeness of comments are not guaranteed.
So friends, today we talked about Role of the Law Commission of India, hope you liked our post.
If you liked the information about Role of the Law Commission of India, then definitely share this article with your friends.
Knowing about laws can make you feel super smart ! If you find value in the content you may consider joining our not for profit Legal Community ! You can ask unlimited questions on WhatsApp and get answers. You can DM or send your name & number to 8208309918 on WhatsApp
