The Parliament Act 1911: Reforming the Powers of the House of Lords

On this page you will read detailed information about Parliament Act 1911.

As a student of British political history, you understand the long struggle for power between the House of Commons and the House of Lords. While the Commons has represented the voice of the people since the 17th century, the Lords retained the power to veto any legislation, stymying reform efforts for generations. This imbalance finally began to shift with the Parliament Act of 1911, which significantly curtailed the Lords’ ability to obstruct the will of the elected Commons. In this article, we will explore the background of the 1911 Act, its immediate impact, and its lasting effects on the relationship between the Commons and Lords. This reform marked a key milestone in Britain’s gradual transition to a full democracy. You will gain insight into how democratic change often occurs incrementally over an extended period of political contestation.

Background: The Struggle Between the House of Commons and House of Lords

The Parliament Act of 1911 was the result of a decades-long power struggle between the House of Commons and the House of Lords. The House of Commons, as the elected chamber, sought to establish itself as the preeminent legislative body in Parliament. However, the House of Lords, composed of hereditary peers and bishops, frequently obstructed the will of the Commons by rejecting or delaying legislation passed by the Commons.

Power of the Purse

The Commons’ primary source of power was its exclusive right to initiate tax legislation under the British constitution. However, the Lords’ power of veto allowed them to reject any legislation, including budget bills. This conflict came to a head in 1909, when the Liberal government in the Commons proposed creating new taxes on land and liquor to fund new social welfare programs. The Conservative-dominated Lords rejected the budget, sparking a constitutional crisis.

The Parliament Act

To resolve the crisis, the Commons passed the Parliament Act 1911, which severely curtailed the Lords’ veto power. Under the Act, the Lords could no longer veto money bills, and could only delay other legislation for two parliamentary sessions or two calendar years. The Act thus established the Commons as the dominant chamber in Parliament.

The passage of the Parliament Act marked a turning point in the democratization of the British political system. By limiting the power of the unelected House of Lords, it shifted more influence to the elected House of Commons, bringing the composition of Parliament more in line with modern democratic principles of representation and accountability. The Act was an important step in the decades-long process of establishing democratic legitimacy and popular sovereignty in Britain.

What Led to the Parliament Act 1911

The early 20th century was marked by a period of political turmoil in Britain due to conflicts between the Liberal government and the Conservative-dominated House of Lords. The Liberal government proposed several controversial bills that were repeatedly rejected by the Lords, who were not elected and held a Conservative majority. This led to a constitutional crisis regarding the powers of the Lords to veto legislation passed by the elected House of Commons.

The People’s Budget

In 1909, the Liberal Chancellor of the Exchequer David Lloyd George introduced the “People’s Budget” which proposed tax increases for the wealthy and social welfare programs for the poor. The budget was passed by the Commons but rejected by the Lords. The Lords’ veto of a budget bill was unprecedented, and the Liberals argued that the Lords had overstepped their constitutional authority.

Limits on the Lords’ Veto

To resolve the crisis, the Liberals proposed limiting the Lords’ veto power over legislation approved by the Commons. However, the king was reluctant to forcibly change the Lords’ powers. The January 1910 election returned the Liberals to power, signaling public support for their reform agenda. Faced with the threat of the king creating hundreds of new Liberal peers to overcome the Conservative majority, the Lords agreed to pass the Parliament Act 1911.

In the previous post, we had shared information about The Trade Union Act 1926: A Legislative Analysis, so read that post also.

The Parliament Act 1911

The Parliament Act 1911 removed the Lords’ veto power over financial legislation and restricted their power to delay other bills. Instead of rejecting bills outright, the Lords could now only delay non-financial legislation for up to two years. The act also reduced the maximum term of a parliament from seven to five years. These reforms marked a significant step toward establishing the democratic primacy of the Commons in the legislative process.

The political crisis of 1909 to 1911 and the resulting Parliament Act marked a turning point in the evolving balance of power between the hereditary nobility and elected representatives in Britain’s constitutional monarchy. By limiting the veto power of the Lords, the Parliament Act enhanced the democratic legitimacy of legislation passed by the House of Commons.

Key Provisions of the Parliament Act 1911

The Parliament Act 1911 redefined the powers of the House of Lords to block legislation passed by the House of Commons. It established the supremacy of the elected House of Commons over the unelected House of Lords in the legislative process.

Removal of the House of Lords’ Absolute Veto

The absolute veto power of the House of Lords was removed. Prior to the Act, the House of Lords could reject any legislation proposed by the House of Commons. Now, the Act stipulated that the House of Lords could only delay, and not veto, revenue bills or bills to extend the life of Parliament. Money bills became law one month after being passed by the Commons, while other public bills became law without the Lords’ consent if passed by the Commons in three successive sessions.

Restriction of the Lords’ Delaying Power

The Parliament Act 1911 restricted the Lords’ ability to delay non-money bills to two years. If the House of Commons passed the bill in three successive sessions, the bill would become law even without the Lords’ consent. This provision further curtailed the powers of the House of Lords and gave more authority to the elected House of Commons.

Salient Impacts

The Parliament Act 1911 has had far-reaching consequences on the British constitutional system. It marked a decisive step towards a fully democratic parliamentary system based on the will of elected representatives in the House of Commons. The supremacy of the Commons was firmly established, and the threat of legislative deadlock between the two Houses was reduced. Overall, the Act made the legislative process more democratic by limiting the obstructionist powers of the unelected House of Lords.

In summary, the key provisions of the Parliament Act 1911 were removing the House of Lords’ absolute veto, restricting their delaying power over legislation, and establishing the dominance of the elected House of Commons in lawmaking. This was a pivotal moment in British political history that shaped the modern parliamentary democracy in Britain.

How the Act Reduced the Lords’ Veto Powers

The Parliament Act of 1911 significantly curtailed the House of Lords’ powers of veto. Prior to the Act, the Lords held absolute veto power over any bill passed by the House of Commons. The Lords frequently used this veto power to block legislation proposed by the Liberal government.

Restricting the Lords’ Veto

The Act stipulated that the Lords could no longer veto a bill passed by the Commons in three consecutive sessions, provided that two years had elapsed between the second reading of the bill in the first session and its passage in the third. This provision severely limited the Lords’ ability to indefinitely block legislation they opposed.

Exempting Financial Bills

Additionally, the Act removed the Lords’ veto power over bills certified as “money bills” by the Speaker of the Commons. Money bills, including the budget, were deemed crucial to the operation of government. By removing the Lords’ veto, the Commons ensured its control over taxation and public expenditure.

Preserving the Lords’ Delaying Powers

However, the Lords retained the power to delay non-money bills for up to two years. While the Lords could no longer veto legislation indefinitely, they could slow down or amend bills during this period. The delay provision allowed additional time for scrutiny and revision of legislation.

The Parliament Act of 1911 marked a pivotal moment in the evolution of Parliament. By curbing the Lords’ absolute veto, the Act tipped the balance of power to the elected Commons. While preserving elements of bicameralism in Parliament, the reforms enhanced democratic governance and the supremacy of the Commons. The Lords’ delaying powers ensured continued deliberation and refinement of legislation. Overall, the 1911 Act made substantial progress in reforming the British constitution and system of government.

Subsequent Changes to the Parliament Act 1911

The Parliament Act 1911 has undergone various amendments since its enactment. In 1949, the Parliament Act 1949 reduced the power of the House of Lords further by restricting its ability to delay bills certified as ‘Money Bills’ by the Speaker of the House of Commons.

Money Bills

Money Bills are public bills that authorize taxes or government expenditure. According to the Parliament Act 1949, the House of Lords cannot delay Money Bills for more than one month. This reform gave more power to the House of Commons over financial matters. In addition, the Salisbury convention established that the House of Lords should not oppose bills promised in the governing party’s election manifesto.

Life Peerages Act 1958

The Life Peerages Act 1958 enabled the appointment of life peers to the House of Lords. Prior to this Act, membership in the House of Lords was hereditary. The introduction of life peerages allowed individuals to serve in the House of Lords based on their own merits and expertise, not based on hereditary titles. Life peers have the right to sit and vote in the House of Lords but cannot pass on their titles to their descendants.

House of Lords Act 1999

The House of Lords Act 1999 significantly reduced the membership of hereditary peers in the House of Lords. Only 92 hereditary peers were allowed to remain as members. The Act also established the House of Lords Appointments Commission to recommend non-party political members for appointment to the House of Lords. This reform moved the House of Lords towards a more modern, accountable and representative institution with members appointed based on merit rather than birthright.

The series of reforms to the Parliament Act 1911 and the wider composition of the House of Lords reflect the gradual democratization of the British political system. The legislative power and composition of the House of Lords have been rebalanced to strengthen the authority of the elected House of Commons. However, additional reforms may be required to improve the representativeness and accountability of the House of Lords.

Significant Legislation Passed Under the Parliament Act

The Parliament Act of 1911 restricted the powers of the House of Lords and gave more authority to the House of Commons. With the passage of this Act, the Commons had the ability to pass bills without the approval of the Lords. This led to the enactment of several important pieces of legislation that improved the lives of British citizens.

People’s Budget of 1909

The People’s Budget of 1909 proposed higher taxes on the wealthy and landowners to fund new social welfare programs. Although the budget passed in the Commons, it was rejected by the Conservative-dominated Lords. The Parliament Act allowed the Commons to pass the budget without the Lords’ consent, enabling new funds for social services like health insurance and pensions for the elderly.

Irish Home Rule Bills of 1912 and 1914

The Irish Home Rule movement sought to establish a devolved parliament in Dublin to govern domestic affairs in Ireland. Home Rule bills were passed by the Commons in 1912 and 1914 but rejected by the Lords. Using the Parliament Act, the Commons was able to approve the bills without the Lords’ approval. However, the outbreak of World War I delayed their implementation, and Ireland did not gain independence until 1921.

Trade Union Act 1913

The Trade Union Act of 1913 legalized picketing and prevented trade unions from facing prosecution for liability. It reversed the Taff Vale Judgment of 1901 which had made unions legally liable for losses incurred during strikes. The bill was passed in the Commons but rejected by the Lords before being approved under the Parliament Act. It gave unions more freedom to organize and take industrial action.

The Parliament Act made the House of Commons the dominant legislative body in Parliament and allowed progressive social legislation to be passed without obstruction from the Lords. It was a pivotal moment in Britain’s political evolution toward a more democratic system of government.

Criticisms and Controversies Surrounding the Act

The Parliament Act of 1911 was not without its detractors and controversies. Some argued that the Act undermined the constitutional role of the House of Lords as a check on the power of the Commons. The Lords had traditionally been able to block legislation passed by the Commons, but after 1911, their veto power was severely curtailed. Critics contended this upset the delicate balance of power in Parliament and gave too much authority to an elected Commons.

Others felt the Act was a politically motivated attempt by the Liberal government to force through controversial legislation like the Irish home rule that the Lords repeatedly rejected. The Liberal government was accused of tampering with the constitution for partisan gains. There were also concerns that the Commons, now unfettered, could pass radical legislation without thoughtful review. Some worried the Act set a precedent for further weakening the Lords in the future.

The royal prerogative allowing the monarch to create peerages was a controversial provision. Critics argued this gave too much power to the prime minister and ruling party over the composition of the Lords. The prime minister could request the monarch create enough friendly peers to pass any legislation blocked by the Lords. Although only used once, this provision threatened the independence of the Lords.

The limitations on the Lords’ power of delay were also controversial. Some felt completely removing their ability to block finance bills weakened their role as part of the budget process. Others thought the two-year limitation on delaying non-finance bills was too short, preventing thoughtful review and revision of complex legislation. However, supporters contended the Lords rarely used their full powers of veto and delay responsibly, so reform was necessary and two years was adequate for most legislation.

The Parliament Act of 1911 addressed the urgent need to reform the House of Lords but remained controversial and imperfect. Like any far-reaching piece of legislation, it had both staunch critics and supporters. Balancing power between an elected Commons and unelected Lords would remain an ongoing challenge in Britain’s evolving parliamentary democracy.

The Parliament Act 1911’s Place in British Constitutional History

The Parliament Act 1911 was a pivotal moment in shaping the modern British constitution. Prior to its passage, the unelected House of Lords held veto power over legislation passed by the elected House of Commons. The Act fundamentally reformed this relationship by removing the Lords’ absolute veto and established the supremacy of the Commons.

The Parliament Act 1911 marked a victory for proponents of democratizing reforms who argued that the hereditary and appointed Lords should not obstruct the will of the elected Commons. For centuries, the House of Lords had used its veto to block progressive social and political legislation. However, by the early 20th century, prevailing views held that the Commons better represented the British people and should prevail in the event of legislative disagreements.

Under the new law, the Lords lost their absolute veto and could only delay, not block, legislation approved by the Commons in three consecutive sessions. If passed in three sessions, the bill would become law without the Lords’ consent. The Parliament Act 1911 applied only to bills relating to public expenditure or the House of Commons’ duration. Nonetheless, it established a crucial constitutional precedent that the elected chamber held primacy in lawmaking.

The Act’s passage demonstrated the Commons’ determination to overcome entrenched opposition to reform. It marked an important victory for elected representatives and signaled the declining power of hereditary privilege in Britain’s political system. At the same time, the Lords retained an ability to delay legislation and force the Commons to reaffirm its positions. This ensured a balance of power, with each chamber checking the other.

In conclusion, the Parliament Act 1911 played a significant role in reforming and stabilizing Britain’s constitutional monarchy. By curbing the Lords’ absolute veto, it strengthened democratic governance and the role of elected politicians in the legislative process. The Act shaped modern conceptions of parliamentary supremacy and the relationship between the Commons and the Lords. Its effects resonate in British politics to this day.

FAQs About the Parliament Act 1911

The Parliament Act 1911 reformed the powers of the House of Lords, the upper chamber of the UK Parliament. If you have questions about this pivotal act in British constitutional history, here are some common FAQs and answers:

The Parliament Act 1911 was a landmark in the evolution of British democracy. By reforming the powers of the House of Lords, it gave more power and independence to the House of Commons, advancing representative democracy in the UK. Despite some criticisms, most historians view it as a progressive act that enabled important social reforms.

Conclusion

As we have seen, the Parliament Act of 1911 was a pivotal moment in the history of Parliament and the balance of power between the House of Commons and the House of Lords. This legislation fundamentally reformed the authority of the House of Lords and strengthened the democratic legitimacy of the Commons. While controversial in its day, the Parliament Act set an important precedent that the elected chamber should prevail over the unelected one. The tensions between the two houses did not disappear overnight, but the Parliament Act marked an irreversible shift towards the supremacy of the Commons. As you reflect on this complex chapter in Britain’s constitutional development, consider both the motivations of those advocating reform and the perspectives of those defending tradition. The passions evoked reveal how the Parliament Act went beyond procedural changes to touch the very heart of democracy and representation. Though a century has passed, the issues at stake continue to shape parliamentary democracy in our own day.

Disclaimer

The information and services on this website are not intended to and shall not be used as legal advice. You should consult a Legal Professional for any legal or solicited advice. While we have good faith and our own independent research to every information listed on the website and do our best to ensure that the data provided is accurate. However, we do not guarantee the information provided is accurate and make no representation or warranty of any kind, express or implied, regarding the accuracy, adequacy, validity, reliability, availability, or completeness of any information on the Site. UNDER NO CIRCUMSTANCES SHALL WE HAVE ANY LIABILITY TO YOU FOR ANY LOSS OR DAMAGE OF ANY KIND INCURRED AS A RESULT OR RELIANCE ON ANY INFORMATION PROVIDED ON THE SITE. YOUR USE OF THE SITE AND YOUR RELIANCE ON ANY INFORMATION ON THE SITE IS SOLELY AT YOUR OWN RISK. Comments on this website are the sole responsibility of their writers so the accuracy, completeness, veracity, honesty, factuality and politeness of comments are not guaranteed.

So friends, today we talked about Parliament Act 1911, hope you liked our post.

If you liked the information about Parliament Act 1911, then definitely share this article with your friends.